Business Answers and Advice
This Question is Possibly Answered
1 "correct" answer available( 4 pts) 2 "helpful" answer s available( 2 pts)Not taking it seriously and jumping in. As marketers, we need to make sure our messages are where our customers are. They are in the social space, so, that's where we need to be as well.
I'd say it's using the wrong platform to reach your target audience.
For example, if you're marketing to the 45+ crowd, spending time and resources building out a presence on MySpace may not be the best use of time or money. Finding the right social media site is key before any type of promotion can be done.![]()
I think lack of planning and forethought is one of the biggest blunders a lot of companies make. They think if they sign up all they have to do is wait for the people to find them. It's never that easy. It doesn't work that way with any other type of advertising or marketing programs. You have to be involved. Social media is just like any other tool. If you don't pick up the hammer and swing it, the nail is never going to move.
Everyone talks about Social Media but most think they can just start by getting more outlets on the web- the usual suspects Facebook, Twitter, Linked In, and others and think that we are here so they will come. It just doesn't happen. Also they think that they can get an intern or low paided newbie to get on that social media thing. Every business should set good montioring tools and then get busy doing nothing but listening to what is being said and by whom and where. Most companies are not going to like what they hear. If they move too quickly, customer service issues get blown up and if they do not have a plan to know how and if they need to engage. The biggest mistake is a leaderless effort and thinking this is just another channel to use as an extention to their marketing effort. If your businesses sucks in any area that touches customers, vendors, or your internal customers- your employees social media or I use the term Social Business because it is a lot more than just "media" you will still suck just in a lot more places.
I have found that many companies and their management believe that social media is a low cost alternative to traditional media when in fact it can be as expensive if not more so. The message they need to get out starts off being delivered by an army of one (or a very small number) to audience that is very small. As time goes on, if the message is compelling (read interesting enough to talk about) perhaps the audience gets larger. There are things that can't be changed in my view and one of them is that the development of new business cost money, lots of it. The difference now is that many of the costs now are hidden or not recognized as costs.
Expert Answer
Peter - I respectfully disagree. Business development is only one benefit of social networking. They jury is still out on its effectiveness for business development too. But it's not money that converts prospects to clients. It's relationships that do. And effective social networking builds relationships.
The benefits of social networking extend beyond business development: public relations, customer support, employee engagement, brand management.
The current problem is that many execs and business owners consider social media as frivilous or patronize it as you mentioned by throwing a few young workers on Facebook. They also attempt to evaluate the ROI based on new sales, while the real benefits may come from improved loyalty, lower turnover, higher customer satisfaction etc.
The costs to initiate and execute an effective social media strategy (blog, Facebook) are mostly labor costs; the delivery costs can be minimal.
And social media has literally leveled the playing field between the haves and have nots. A small business can now effectively compete with a competitor many times larger with deeper pockets. While money might buy ad space and air time, it won't build relationships. Going forward the business with the best relationships will control the market.
Ira Wolfe
Dr. Ira Wolfe is a speaker and adviser on workforce trends, social media and employee assessments. He is president of Success Performance Solutions, which advises companies on hiring and retention. Ira is a frequent speaker at conferences, organizations and Vistage groups.
He is the author of "Geeks, Geezers, and Googlization" (2009), a look at how to bridge the generational gap in the workplace, and "The Perfect Labor Storm 2.0: Workforce Trends That Will Change The Way You Do Business (2007)." Ira also writes on Bizmore about social media, workforce trends, and employee assesments. You can also follow his twitter account.
Thanks for your response to my note Ira Ira. I obviously wasn't clear in my answer because I agree fully with you on the relationship building aspect of social media and the importance of relationships to success. What I could have said, and it would have been clearer, is that management sometimes believes that relationship building done by social media is a low cost option to other types of relationship building when in fact it isn't. It takes a lot of time to build a relationship and that time costs money. The other side, which you pointed out, is the management which dismisses Social Media out of hand as a fad and that too will become very expensive since businesses which don't embrace new ideas, of all kinds, will be destined to fail because they will be uncompetitive.
Expert Answer
Ira - I certainly agree with all you've said. I'd like to add 2 more points into the discussion.
Problem #1 - putting the what before the why.
Perhaps an even bigger mistake than not getting involved at all, is getting involved without a clear line of sight between the actions taken in social media and the results you hope to achieve. You can waste weeks of time in social media if that work is not done up front. Typically, this should be driven by somebody with a good grasp on business strategy AND the social media tools at their disposal. And in that, I would err on the side of "good grasp of business strategy".
Problem #2 - taking a "wait and see" approach
Nobody wants to be the pioneer with the arrows in their backs - so they wait and see what their competitors are doing and then respond accordingly. The problem with this is that the ones who are figuring the space out aren't figuring out which sales message works best on Twitter or Facebook, they are building communities that allow them to put their customers at the center of their business model. The companies and brands who do this first will win, because along with media abundance comes attention scarcity. I will quite literally not have the time to pay attention to you if I'm already paying attention to your competitor, and they are doing a good job of community building.
In 2010, your participation in social media will be your biggest opportunity AND your biggest threat.
Steve Cunningham
Steve is the CEO of Polar Limited, a digital marketing and innovation agency where he and his team serve some of the most progressive thinkers in the healthcare, hi-tech, home comfort and not-for-profit industries. He is a frequent speaker to groups of CEOs across North America on the power of social media and innovative web content to transform the way businesses run, and ultimately win in the marketplace.
Steve also writes The Social Business on Bizmore, a blog that focuses on social media tactics and tools.
I tend to agree with Ira. The biggest mistake many employers are making of late is an attempt to evaluate the ROI based on new sales, while the real benefits may come from improved loyalty, lower turnover, higher customer satisfaction etc.. (Also sad to say that lost sales outpace new sales in many industries - a comparative measurement for retention also seems warranted on the new sales basis.)
I would take this idea one step further and say that the ROI equation is being applied unilaterally, with regard to anything considered an overhead expense, including company personnel. Stated succintly, The tangible and immediate is taking greater precedence over the intangible (non-measurable) and the long-term.
Generally, smaller businesses currently have an advantage in the social media market as they are most willing to embrace change while established businesses are most concerned with preserving their bottom lines.SM is yet to be recognized as a priority for most until it can be proven to lead to a tangible revenue source. The prevailing mindset among many is that SM is simply seen as another way to spend when most companies are still searching for ways to reduce the expenses already appearing on their P&L's.
The biggest blunder of Management in my opinion is what I refer to a Short-sighted Mouse-vision. .
The biggest blunders are either assuming social media is "the one all-purpose medium for all future marketing" or "a kid-oriented fad."
Social media is well suited for some marketing tasks -- and very poorly suited for others. The trick is to know which ones. See my post on a related topic here:
http://www.bizmore.com/portal/message/4497#4497
Al Shultz
Expert Answer
There are so many, it would take a book to cover it all, but the one that stands out the most is "ignorance".
So many managers ignore social media (sm), comforting themselves that social media is not important in their market. Many think sm is the future, a place to visit in the future, but best left alone right now.
Simply put if you are in business, you cannot ignore social media.
Your customers are part of it and they expect you to be part of it.
I have seen business managers ignore their thousands of followers in social media platforms. When a manger ignores its followers the message is clear: "You don't matter. What you say doesn't matter. We have nothing to say to you." This type of mentality is detrimental in the short term, and devastating in the long term.
I have seen some fortune 500 companies ignoring customer feedback about their product or downplaying customer outcry about their advertising campaigns only to learn there was a huge price to pay.
George Meszaros
George is the CEO of Webene, a leading web presence solutions provider and new media marketing firm. Webene specializes in web design, graphic design, e-commerce solutions, web application development, custom content management systems (CMS), Internet marketing, Pay Per Click management, Search Engine Optimization, email marketing, and web analytics. Author of Triumph On The Web ? Revolutionize Your Business With Simple Online Strategies. He earned an MBA with an emphasis on Technology Management and an M.S. in Computer Information Systems. He has been a Vistage member since 2005.
Because I'm young I've had the experience to be on both sides of the business social networks. I receive their posts and also do the posting. I think the most important thing is to keep people interested with personal posts. Smashing Magazine said it best in this post
Tweeting on a corporate account or posting sales demonstrations on YouTube misses the essence of social networking.
Social networking is about people engaging with people. Individuals do not want to build relationships with brands and corporations. They want to talk to other people. Too many organizations throw millions into Facebook apps and viral videos when they could spend that money on engaging with people in a transparent and open away.
Instead of creating a corporate Twitter account or indeed even a corporate blog, encourage your employees to start Tweeting and blogging themselves. Provide guidelines on acceptable behavior and what tools they need to start engaging directly with the community connected to your products and services. This demonstrates not only your commitment to the community but also the human side of your business.
Expert Answer
Business owners and senior executives are generally hands-on managers when it comes to sales and marketing. In fact, they often micro-manage sales and marketing initiatives to the point of interference. However when it comes to social media, they tend to give it a superficial shrug and delegate it to the youngest staffer, intern, or child. So I agree with several of the comments that strategy and planning is ignored.
The single biggest blunder that I continue to see being made is that a business delegates setting up a business page on Facebook to a staffer or even a web developer, not realizing that whoever sets up the page permanantly is the master administrator of the account. Currently there is no way to transfer "ownership" of the page from one admin to another. A second and equally serious blunder is using the personal profile as the business page. That explicitly is a violation of Facebook's terms and conditions and they will disable your account if you violate that provision.
Ira Wolfe
Dr. Ira Wolfe is a speaker and adviser on workforce trends, social media and employee assessments. He is president of Success Performance Solutions, which advises companies on hiring and retention. Ira is a frequent speaker at conferences, organizations and Vistage groups.
He is the author of "Geeks, Geezers, and Googlization" (2009), a look at how to bridge the generational gap in the workplace, and "The Perfect Labor Storm 2.0: Workforce Trends That Will Change The Way You Do Business (2007)." Ira also writes on Bizmore about social media, workforce trends, and employee assesments. You can also follow his twitter account.
Expert Answer
What everyone says here is correct. The biggest problem I see most companies make is hiring someone fresh from college and letting them handle the conversation on the social networks. As has been evidenced by Habitat and, most recently Southwest Airlines (with the Kevin Smith debacle), new college graduates are helpful in setting up the platforms, once companies figure out where their audiences are participating online, but to make them the face of your brand on the social networks is equal to having them run your customer service department, being your television spokesperson, or presenting to the board.
Gini Dietrich
Gini is the founder of Arment Dietrich, Inc., a Chicago-based firm that teaches companies how to use online communication for business growth. She has a passion for Global Domination and cycling.
As CEO, Gini works with c-level executives on using online technology to develop and foster relationships for better and more efficient communication. Her team works to develop strategies that build communities, generate leads, cultivate those leads, and convert them...all while tying efforts to improved profitability.
Resources
- Business Questions
- Business Insights
- Small Business Magazines
- Register for Free
- Networks & Groups
- Bizmore Blog
- Advice from Experts
Copyright
- © Bizmore, Inc 2010
- All Rights Reserved
Company
Ask a Question via Twitter
Send a question to @askbizmore and we will share it with the community and notify you when you receive an answer.
Ask a Question
Got a question for the experts at Bizmore?
Bizmore is an online business advice community that helps people build their businesses and succeed in their careers. Whether you work at a startup, a small business or a large corporation, you can quickly find practical answers to your business questions from peers and industry experts.




